Sweet shops with ice cream, frozen yogurt and candy, and bakeries.


West Lake Drive Extension- at the Harbor

Celebrating their 29th year in Montauk serving Vermont’s “Best”, Fair Trade, GMO free ice cream, frozen Greek yogurt and fresh fruit sorbets. This year, introducing B&J's NON-DAIRY frozen dessert. Experience our “thick” shakes, creamy soft serve, fresh fruit (low calorie) smoothies and sorbet splashes. Visit the adjoining Espresso bar featuring locally roasted Fair Trade Organic coffee (from the Hampton Coffee Co.) and an assortment of teas, treats, gift items, and the East End's largest variety of B&J's "pints to go!" Open Memorial Day weekend, seven days a week late June-Labor Day.


41 S Edgemere St

On the Circle, just off Main Street, Fudge N'Stuff is jam-packed with goodies, including 30 different kinds of fudge, and they’ll slice you a taste so you can sample until you find your favorite. An eye-popping assortment of old-fashioned penny candy, lollipops, gourmet jellybeans, cotton candy, hot popcorn, nuts, and chocolate-covered pretzels by the pound. Or order an ice-cream cone, sundae, malt, or banana split, or a hot chocolate or cappuccino. They sell piñatas for your parties. Open from 10am until 11pm, 7 days in season. No credit cards.


805 Montauk Highway

Located at the east end of the village, the Montauk Market serves breakfast and lunch daily and also serves up bagels, flagels, bialys, pies, cookies, and all those wonderful pastries to be enjoyed any time of the day. They make a full breakfast, including egg white wraps, burritos, omelets, French toast, pancakes, fresh fruit salad, yogurt & granola and natural veggie juices and smoothies. The menu for lunch includes thirty different sandwich combos, and homemade salads. Serving hot and cold platters for dinner with Italian specialties and Latin-American dishes. Let them make you a basket to take to the beach. Catering and specialty cakes and pies made to order.


29 The Plaza

Line up for great coffee and morning sweets! Besides their Famous Jelly Croissant, the Bake Shoppe has other morning pastries and Artisanal breads. This is the place to order your wedding cakes and special occasion cakes. Open from 6am daily. in season.

Buddha Berry

Candied Anchor