montauk dining - markets, confectionaries, bakeries, wine/beer/liquors

Montauk is noted for the freshest seafood, and for excellent presentations prepared by our local chefs. Unless otherwise noted, these restaurants are not open during the winter months.

Four Oaks

Open Year-round
At the entrance to Montauk Harbor on Flamingo and West Lake Drive, this deli serves up breakfast specials along with lunch and dinner specials daily. Start your day with homemade fresh bagels, flagels, bialys and fresh-roasted coffee. For a great break or after the beach come here for homemade ice cream, smoothies and more. Take-out, or enjoy dining outside at the Outdoor Cafe. This deli also prepares box lunches! Open year-round, from 5am-10pm daily in season. Major credit cards. 668-253

Dee-Licious Bagels

Open Year-round weekends

Just like the name promises, this shop across from St. Therese’s Church on South Etna has a full array of bagels and spreads, as well as egg sandwiches and pastries at breakfast time. For lunch, there are specialty salads, paninis and wraps. Also check out their new menu items, along with coffee, takeout sandwiches, drinks, and snacks to go. This year they have expanded their baked goods selections, and have specialty cupcakes. For special occasions, Deelicious Bagels can provide gift baskets, party platters, and decorated cakes. 668-4909

Herb's Montauk Market

Open Year-round
herbsmontaukmarket.com
Mention Herb’s and many recall its famous fried chicken. Order early to be sure to get yours. Herb’s, on Main Street in the Village, also has great sandwiches, finger-lickin’ barbecued ribs, rotisserie chicken, a fresh fruit salad bar, prime meats cut to order (including all-natural chicken) and all the rest of the fixings a good old-fashioned deli can provide. They also have a hot bar serving their famous fried chicken by the piece along with side dishes. Giant heroes and specialty gift baskets may be ordered. Major credit cards. 668-2335

Marshall's

Open Year-round
This Main Street service station has a handy convenience store, open for coffee and snacks, summer drinks, plus cool imported beers. Open from 7-10, seven days, in season, and 6-8, in the winter. Major credit cards. 668-2990

Montauk Beer & Soda

Open Year-round
Montauk Beer & Soda at 43 South Elmwood Avenue is stocked with every beverage you can think of, from soda to water to mixers, and a large selection of imported and domestic lagers and ales in six packs or kegs. They also carry BBQ gas, firewood, fire logs, charcoal, chips and ice; bring your packages that need mailing because they ship UPS as well. No credit cards, but a secure ATM is inside and delivery is available. 668-5400

Fudge N Stuff

Closed for the season. A sweet tooth’s dream, Fudge N’Stuff, on the Circle just off Main Street, is jam-packed with goodies, including 30 different kinds of fudge, and, yes, they’ll slice you a taste so you can sample until you find your favorite. An eye-popping assortment of old-fashioned penny candy, lollipops, gourmet jellybeans, cotton candy, hot popcorn, nuts, and chocolate-covered pretzels by the pound. Or order an ice-cream cone, sundae, malt, or banana split, or a hot chocolate or cappuccino. Cravings satisfied from 10am until 11pm, seven days in season. No credit cards. 668-4724

Rita's Farm Stand

Closed for the season. Rita Foster operates a farm stand with fresh vegetables and fresh free range eggs. On West Lake Drive 668-5453