montauk dining - markets, confectionaries, bakeries, wine/beer/liquors

Montauk is noted for the freshest seafood, and for excellent presentations prepared by our local chefs.

 

 

Four Oaks (Open All Year)

fouroaksdeli.com

At the entrance to Montauk Harbor on Flamingo and West Lake Drive, this deli serves up daily specials for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Start your day with homemade bagels, flagels, bialys, fresh OJ and fruit, and fresh-roasted coffee. Preparing vegetarian and Italian specialties and box lunches, and new this season —
delicious tapas of ceviche (seafood). For a great break or after the beach come here for homemade ice cream, natural smoothies and more. Take-out, or enjoy dining outside at the Outdoor Cafe. Open daily, year-round, from 5 am until 10pm, in-season. Major credit cards. 668-2534

 

 

Herb's Montauk Market (Open All Year)

www.herbsmontaukmarket.com
Mention Herb's and many recall its famous fried chicken. Order early to be sure to get yours. Herb's, on Main Street in the Village, also has great sandwiches, a fresh fruit salad bar, prime meats cut to order (including all-natural chicken) and all the fixings a good, old-fashioned deli can provide. You will also find gluten free items on the menu, and gourmet groceries on the shelves. A hot bar serves their famous fried chicken by the piece along with finger-lickin' barbecued ribs and chicken, rotisserie chicken, and side dishes. Voted "Best Fried Chicken on the East End" by the East Hampton Star. Giant heroes and specialty gift baskets may be ordered. Major credit cards. 668-2335

 

 

La Pasticceria (Open All Year)

www.beach-bakery.com
The wholesale Beach Bakery at Gurney's Inn. Pies, cakes, cookies and more sold all over Montauk and the Hamptons

 

 

Marshall's (Open All Year)

This Main Street service station has a handy convenience store, open for coffee and snacks, summer drinks, plus cool, imported beers, and fine humidor cigars. Open from 5:30 -11, seven days, in-season, and 6-9, in the winter. Major credit cards. 668-2990

 

 

 

Michael's Kitchen

michaelskitchenonline.com

New to Montauk this year is a catering and take-out kitchen at 34 South Etna Ave. Michael brings his years of experience catering on the North Fork to Montauk, delivering lobster and clam bakes, seafood, and other fare to your home, beach or business. Michael also has a large selection of wraps, paninis, salads, sandwiches, and daily specials for breakfast, lunch and dinner. A great place to get that smoothie, frappe or cappucino. Order quality food to cater your next party or event, and also get that same fine food to take-out. Open 7 days in-season. Major credit cards. 668-4909

 

 

Montauk Bake Shoppe

www.montaukbakeshoppe.com

Montauk Bake Shoppe, on the Plaza, where devoted customers line up for great coffee and morning sweets. Besides their Famous Jelly Croissant, there is the Cruffin, a muffin-crumb cake with cream cheese and the fruit of the day inside, muffins, cinnamon swirls, and other great choices. Artisanal breads range from a chewy ciabatta to the buttermilk loaf. Breakfast wraps and egg sandwiches available until 1pm, with iced espresso or cappuccino in the summer. Lunch, until 4 daily, with a choice of three soups, quiche and more. Wedding cakes a specialty. Open from St. Patrick's Day to Thanksgiving from 6am. No credit cards. 668-2439

 

 

Montauk Beer & Soda

Montauk Beer & Soda at their expanded location at 43 South Elmwood Avenue is stocked with even more of every beverage you can think of, from soda to water to mixers, and a large selection of imported and domestic lagers and ales in six packs or kegs. They also carry BBQ gas, firewood, fire logs, charcoal, chips and ice; bring your packages that need mailing because they ship UPS as well. No credit cards, but a secure ATM is inside and delivery is available. 668-5400

 

 

Fudge N Stuff

A sweet tooth's dream, Fudge N'Stuff, on the Circle just off Main Street, is jam-packed with goodies, including 30 different kinds of fudge, and, yes, they'll slice you a taste so you can sample until you find your favorite. An eye-popping assortment of old-fashioned penny candy, lollipops, gourmet jellybeans, cotton candy, hot popcorn, nuts, and chocolate-covered pretzels by the pound. Or order an ice-cream cone, sundae, malt, or banana split, or a hot chocolate or cappuccino. They also sell piñatas for your
parties. Cravings satisfied from 10am until 11pm, seven days in-season. No credit cards. 668-4724

 

When Pigs Fly

www.whenpigsflymtk.com

Montauk's BBQ shack at 10 South Etna Ave. in the Village, is not just ribs & pulled pork. This family run take-out restaurant specializes in tacos, hot wings, hamburgers, fried chicken, appetizers, wraps, sandwiches, lobster rolls and more. A great place to take the kids with 40 items $10.00 and under. Outdoor seating. Open for lunch and dinner. Credit cards. 668-8070