Montauk Hotels: Montauk Harbor

On Montauk’s north side, the harbor area is home to the largest fishing fleet in New York State, both commercial and recreational. It’s also home to shops, restaurants, and hotels and motels.

Culloden House

540 West Lake Drive Montauk, NY 11954

Open March-October
In the Harbor Area, owned and operated by the Gosman family
Rooms, some efficiencies, and one apartment. Short walk to restaurants, shops, markets, fishing, ferries

371 West Lake Drive Montauk, NY 11954

Open all year
Located in the Harbor Area, a short walk to boats, shops and the beach
27 newly renovated units with pool, tennis, kitchenettes, A/C

Montauk Yacht Club


32 Star Island Road


103 nautically-inspired guest rooms, suites and villas with private balcony or patio, each with water or resort views. Luxurious accommodations, wi-fi, restaurants,  bar, spa, marina, indoor and outdoor pools, fitness center, tennis. Small dogs welcomed.

Montauk Soundview
6 Soundview Drive, Montauk NY 11954

Open May-October
A uniquely styled resort hotel, ideally located along the serene coast of the Block Island Sound, 350 yards West of the Montauk Harbor Inlet. Offering 23 units including 1 Bedroom Units, 1 Room Efficiencies, 2 Room Suites, 4 Room Cottages, 4 Room Waterfront Cottages, and 4 Room Waterfront Apartments. All have decks or porches and offer outside dining.Offering a heated pool, private beach, lounge and BBQ, children's beach with a public beach close by.

Sail Inn
548 W Lake Dr Montauk, NY 11954

Open all year
Friendly small inn with 10 units right in the Harbor area with a restaurant on premises.

Snug Harbor
3 Star Island Road Montauk, NY 11954

Open March-November
Beautiful harbor front efficiencies, located in the Harbor Area, directly on the water
34 units with pool, kitchen, A/C, pets allowed in some units

Sun N Sound
22 Soundview Driv, Montauk, NY 11954

Open May-October
Waterfront property, overlooking Block Island Sound and just a short walk to Montauk Harbor with restaurants, shops fishing and ferries.
35 units all with full kitchens. Most units have sliding glass doors which open onto private decks overlooking the water. Pool and patio with lounge chairs and tables.

Uihlein's Motel
10 Wells Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

Open all year
Friendly small motel with 7 units in the Harbor equipped with full kitchens, flat screen TV, wifi, A/C. Grounds has BBQs, a putting green w/mini golf course, play area and room to relax. Discount on boat rentals.